Ex 6-29 “I-Statements” (25 Minutes)

The Challenge: “You-statements” focus on blaming or attacking the other person, which immediately triggers defensiveness and shuts down productive communication. “I-statements” focus instead on your own feelings, objective facts, the real-world impact, and a clear request for the future.

The Formula:

I feel [Emotion] + when [Specific, Objective Behavior] + because [Impact or Reason] + and moving forward, I need [Clear Request or Boundary].

---

Directions:

Act as a “Script Doctor.” Read each high-friction statement below, identify the underlying issue, and rewrite it into a civil, boundary-setting I-statement.

Group 1: Personal Space & Boundaries

1. “You are always borrowing my things without asking and you never put them back where they belong.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
2. “You just push your way into my conversations and completely take over the room.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
3. “You never clean up after yourself in the shared space, and you expect everyone else to be your maid.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
4. “You are constantly checking your phone and texting while I am trying to talk to you.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
5. “You need to back off and give me some space because you are completely suffocating me right now.”
   • Your Edit:
     \

Group 2: Communication & Collaboration

1. “You always cut me off in the middle of my sentences because you think your ideas are more important.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
2. “You never listen to a single word I say; everything just goes in one ear and out the other.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
3. “You are being completely unreasonable and stubborn about this change.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
4. “You never communicate what is actually going on, and then you leave me to deal with the mess.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
5. “You need to stop talking down to me like I am a child who doesn’t understand anything.”
   • Your Edit:
     \

Group 3: Time, Reliability & Commitments

1. “You are always late to our meetings and you clearly don’t care about wasting my time.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
2. “You just dumped this entire project on my lap at the last minute because you were too lazy to finish it.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
3. “You completely flaked on your part of our agreement, and now I have to bail you out again.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
4. “You never respond to my messages in a timely manner, forcing me to sit around waiting for you.”
   • Your Edit:
     \
5. “You are micromanaging every single detail of my work because you don’t trust me at all.”
   • Your Edit:
     \

---

Facilitator Guide & Answer Key

• Acknowledge the Difficulty: Remind participants that “I-statements” can feel clunky or unnatural at first. The goal is clarity and civil boundary-setting, not poetic speech.
• Watch out for “Fake” I-Statements: Participants will often try to say, “I feel like you are being rude.” Point out that “I feel like you…” is just a hidden “You-statement.” An authentic emotion must follow “I feel…” (e.g., “I feel frustrated”).
• Focus on Objectivity: In the “when [behavior]” section, emphasize removing loaded words like “always,” “never,” “lazy,” or “disrespectful.” Stick to video-camera facts.

Group 1: Personal Space & Boundaries

1. “You are always borrowing my things without asking and you never put them back where they belong.”

• Core Issue: Lack of permission; misplaced property.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel frustrated when my supplies are borrowed without prior notice and left in a different spot, because I lose time searching for them when I need to work. Moving forward, I need you to ask before taking my items and to return them to my desk when finished.”

2. “You just push your way into my conversations and completely take over the room.”

• Core Issue: Interrupting an ongoing conversation.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel disconnected when new voices join a conversation before we finish our current thought, because the original topic gets lost. Moving forward, I need us to complete our exchange before opening up the floor to a larger group discussion.”

3. “You never clean up after yourself in the shared space, and you expect everyone else to be your maid.”

• Core Issue: Leftover messes in shared environments.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel overwhelmed when dishes and papers are left on the common tables, because it restricts others from using the space comfortably. Moving forward, I need everyone to clear their personal items immediately after finishing their lunch or project.”

4. “You are constantly checking your phone and texting while I am trying to talk to you.”

• Core Issue: Divided attention / phone distraction.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel unheard when phones are out during our 1-on-1 check-ins, because it feels like our conversation doesn’t have your full focus. Moving forward, I need us to keep our devices away during these brief alignment sessions.”

5. “You need to back off and give me some space because you are completely suffocating me right now.”

• Core Issue: Needing immediate emotional or physical space to process.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel smothered and anxious when we try to resolve an issue immediately during a tense moment, because I don’t have the mental clarity to think straight. Moving forward, I need to take a 10-minute solo break before we finish discussing this problem.”

---

Group 2: Communication & Collaboration

6. “You always cut me off in the middle of my sentences because you think your ideas are more important.”

• Core Issue: Verbal interruption during presentations or meetings.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel dismissed when I am spoken over before completing my sentence, because I am unable to share my full input with the team. Moving forward, I need to finish my thought entirely before opening the floor to feedback.”

7. “You never listen to a single word I say; everything just goes in one ear and out the other.”

• Core Issue: Lack of active listening or confirmation.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel unsupported when instructions or feedback aren’t acknowledged, because I am left unsure if we are aligned on the task. Moving forward, I need a quick email confirmation or verbal nod to know the message was received.”

8. “You are being completely unreasonable and stubborn about this change.”

• Core Issue: Resisting an organizational or procedural shift.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel stuck when we choose not to explore alternative processes, because our current workflow is causing operational delays. Moving forward, I need us to look at the data for this new system with an open mind during Tuesday’s meeting.”

9. “You never communicate what is actually going on, and then you leave me to deal with the mess.”

• Core Issue: Lack of status updates leading to reactive crisis management.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel blindsided when project updates aren’t shared regularly, because it forces me to resolve unexpected emergencies at the final hour. Moving forward, I need a weekly 5-minute status email on Fridays regarding your milestones.”

10. “You need to stop talking down to me like I am a child who doesn’t understand anything.”

• Core Issue: Condescending tone or simplified explanations.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel belittled when basic explanations are delivered using a sharp or repetitive tone, because I have several years of experience in this role. Moving forward, I need us to speak as professional peers when mapping out these project guidelines.”

---

Group 3: Time, Reliability & Commitments

11. “You are always late to our meetings and you clearly don’t care about wasting my time.”

• Core Issue: Tardiness impacting schedules.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel stressed when our meetings start 15 minutes after the scheduled time, because it pushes back the rest of my daily calendar. Moving forward, I need us to arrive precisely at the start time, or receive a text notification if you are running late.”

12. “You just dumped this entire project on my lap at the last minute because you were too lazy to finish it.”

• Core Issue: Last-minute task delegation without warning.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel unduly pressured when large action items are handed off to me on the day they are due, because I lack the necessary time to guarantee high-quality work. Moving forward, I need at least 48 hours of advance notice before a project is transferred to my queue.”

13. “You completely flaked on your part of our agreement, and now I have to bail you out again.”

• Core Issue: Missed collaborative deliverables.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel frustrated when assigned sections of a group project go unsubmitted by the internal deadline, because the rest of the team must scramble to absorb the extra workload. Moving forward, I need honesty about capacity issues early so we can reallocate tasks fairly.”

14. “You never respond to my messages in a timely manner, forcing me to sit around waiting for you.”

• Core Issue: Delayed digital communication responses.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel blocked when messages regarding active files go unanswered for more than a business day, because I cannot proceed with the next steps of production. Moving forward, I need a brief acknowledgement or response within 4 hours for high-priority inquiries.”

15. “You are micromanaging every single detail of my work because you don’t trust me at all.”

• Core Issue: Excessive oversight / lack of professional autonomy.
• Suggested Answer: “I feel restricted when my daily drafts are reviewed multiple times an hour, because it breaks my concentration and slows down my workflow. Moving forward, I need us to establish a single, daily checkpoint check-in to review progress instead.”