California voters in every county except far left San Francisco County and far right Orange County approved Proposition 14 which changes the state constitution to require the primary election to select the two highest vote recipients, without respect to their political party.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_14_(2010)

California may once again be on the leading edge of American history.  This change seems to be a rejection of the current primary system where candidates in both parties are required to pander to the extremists and activists before tacking back to the center to win in general elections.  Ironically, the Tea Party movement seems to be tapping some of this frustration by the average centrist voter, while at the same time pulling the Republican Party even further to the right.

In the shadow of “The Great War”, William Butler Yeats wrote:

Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.

http://www.online-literature.com/donne/780/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Second_Coming_(poem)

The optimistic progressive consensus of 1880-1910 among the leading classes had been severely weakened by the war.  World War II shattered the last idealistic sentiments in Europe, leading to the post-war time of European community, skepticism and limited idealism.  The United States picked up the progressive banner with the New Deal, WWII, post-war global organizations and economic recovery, the cold war, New Frontier and Great Society.  Temporarily derailed by the Vietnam War, Energy Crisis and Japanese competition, the U.S. once again embraced the optimistic progressive spirit in the 1980’s, but with a distinctively right-wing flavor following the Reagan revolution.  Twenty years of economic and geopolitical progress delivered a new sense of American exceptionalism, leading to the Bush administration’s overreach in Iraq in response to the perceived terrorist threats after 9/11.   Most commentators agree that we now face a more uncertain multi-polar future (see 2/1/2010).

How did the American public reach this point where most voters clearly see that the political system does not work (see 1/26/2010)? 

Congressional and state legislator gerrymandering has played a major role.  The average voter can see that many legislators are simply incompetent party hacks with extremist, populist rhetoric, but no sense of responsibility for governing on behalf of the citizens.  The advantages of incumbents have lead to their re-election and increased voter cynicism (see 12/12/2009).    This year, unprepared voters elected Alvin Greene as the Democratic SC senate candidate and nominal Democrat, 29 year-old Tim Crawford to oppose Dan Burton.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering

As the financial and volunteer resources required for election have grown, the power of extremist/activist groups in both political parties has grown significantly.   As the country’s population and standard of living have grown, narrow economically rational voters have reduced their participation, thereby increasing the power of those with strong ideological views.

Citizens of all political views have become more independent, decreasing the role of many individual and institutional influencers who once promoted the center (think US News & World Report in the 1960’s).   Politicians and political parties have become far more sophisticated in identifying and capturing the resources of those with the strongest beliefs.

After the break-up of the Democratic Party’s “solid south” position following passage of the 1960’s civil rights legislation, the Republican Party developed a more philosophically consistent right wing position on all economic, military and cultural issues.  The Democrats have tried to move towards the center, but the left-right and Democratic-Republican dimensions of American politics have become synonymous for almost 40 years.  The Republicans have effectively attracted millions of Catholic, Baptist, working and middle class voters from Democratic strongholds, while the Democrats have rode demographic trends and recaptured some socially moderate and upper middle class voters on the coasts.

The modern media has returned to its 19^th century roots, adopting explicit political and populist positions in order to sell advertising.  This promotes partisan posturing and coverage.

Politics no longer attracts citizen legislators with moderate views.  Political positions have very low compensation compared with other options for highly competent citizens.  The price of entering a campaign is so high that only individuals with hopes for a 20 year political career, radical idealists or the very wealthy rationally pursue elected office.

Non-party primaries, campaign finance reform, independent districting commissions and grass-roots political participation can all help to return our political system to the center, where reasonable compromises can be found for the benefit of all.  Without some structural changes, we run the risk of having the divisive and unproductive political results seen in Italy, Greece, Mexico, Venezuela, Japan and Germany.  A solid majority of the American people desire centrist solutions to our challenges.  Structural changes can help to ensure that we have a self-improving system, or at least that we do not see “things fall apart”.