A friend of mine has been a highly successful CFO with middle market companies for 25 years.  I pondered what made him succeed in a variety of companies and industries.

 He’s professionally competent and intellectually curious.  He’s always had a large professional network.  He is a good listener and is especially skilled at cutting through ambiguous or complex situations to identify the core problem or most promising solution.  He understands the basis for business success in his industry and he’s a good negotiator.

 On the other hand, he’s sometimes overly direct, not a technical leader in the CPA profession, not someone who automatically attracts the spotlight, doesn’t outsmart the quantitative business analysts and doesn’t often lead cross-functional projects.

 I think he succeeds because he has established a role and the skills to guide all key players to honestly confront the gray reality of situations.  He offers the financial perspective, but is just as quick to insert a sales, strategy or cultural viewpoint.  He ensures that risk versus return is considered through numbers, stories and analogies.  He contrasts short-term with long-term factors.  He plays devil’s advocate as needed to derail quick decisions or to shore up support for a tough alternative that must be chosen.

 In addition to these decision making skills, he has the wisdom, courage and skills to anticipate the perspectives of the key roles and to guide players into greater self-awareness and understanding of other perspectives.

 He helps finance, accounting, HR and IT staff to see that the fully integrated system and a 1,000 page policy and procedure document, without exceptions, is probably too structured.  He encourages engineers and six sigma black belts to reduce variation and to consider financial and strategic implications.

 He works with entrepreneurial owners to support change and risk taking, but to also gauge how much can be digested, how it can be hedged and what an ideal portfolio looks like.

 He works with boards and shareholders to understand that stock values do not always go up in a predictable manner, unless the books have been “managed”.  The long-term growth in shareholder value includes short-term fluctuations.

 He works with IT, engineering and product developers to have resources, time and authority to learn, experiment and develop new products – within a framework of long-term evaluation.

 He provides sales and marketing teams with the freedom and flexibility to meet company goals, but ensures that measures of final results are fair and the system can’t be beat.

 The effective CFO serves as a fulcrum in Jim Collins’ world of “both/and”.  Stakeholders and role players must be able to leverage their talents and preferred styles AND the contrasting factors which must also be considered for long run success.  CFO’s need to be more than gray; they need to be both black AND white.